Another month has gone by, which means it’s time for another Round Robin, and author Rhobin Courtwright has come up with yet another great topic for us: “Have you noticed how weather is used in writing? How have you used weather in your writing? Drama? Mood? Revelation?”
I absolutely love all forms of symbolism in writing and art. Even when the symbolism isn’t subtle, I still really enjoy it. As far as I’m concerned, there’s no such thing as OTT with symbolism, and I especially love spotting it in films – the good guy riding the white horse, the bird flying away to symbolise freedom, the rainbow symbolising hope, etc, etc.
I first discovered writers could use the weather as a symbol in their stories when I was at school. The book we were studying was A Handful of Dust, by Evelyn Waugh, and I was struck by how the author used the weather to mirror what was going on for the protagonist. This was when I first learned the term “pathetic fallacy”. Pathetic fallacy actually means giving human abilities to the weather or nature – eg “the sun was smiling”, or “the daffodils danced”. Of course the sun doesn’t really smile and flowers can’t dance – that’s why it’s a “fallacy”- but writers often use pathetic fallacy to reflect what’s happening to their characters. Even if the symbolism is so subtle the reader doesn’t directly notice, it can still subconsciously affect their mood and the way they react to what’s happening.
I’ve used the weather/nature as symbolism a few times in my own writing. In Penny’s Antique Shop of Memories and Treasures, for example, the hero, Kurt Bold, is walking home from an evening with the heroine. He still doesn’t realise yet that he’s in love with her. It’s a clear, cold night. When he looks up, the sky should be as bright and starry as it would have been in his home in Wyoming, but because he’s in London, all he can see is the neon of the streetlights. The stars are hidden – just like his own emotions.
The weather plays a much bigger role in my novel The Summer of Love and Secrets. For the first half of the novel, the heat in the city of London is stifling, and the heroine, Kate, is deeply unsettled and has trouble sleeping. The weather mirrors her own restless emotions. Then the weather breaks, and the resulting storm is vital as a symbol. It’s a scene in which the hero, Paul, is persuading Kate to see her dad – the man who abandoned her as a child. I’ve put the full extract here, so you can see how important the break in the heat and the sudden downpour is to the play of emotions.
Paul put his hand on Kate’s arm, and she stared down at it, full of rage. ‘Please. It’s important. Come inside and give the guy a chance.’
She shook off his hand. ‘Like he gave me a chance, you mean?’ She turned on her heel. ‘I can’t even believe what I’m hearing.’
The rain was falling in sheets now, dripping from her hair in wet streaks. Kate blinked the water out of her eyes and stumbled as she walked away. Instantly Paul was at her side, steadying her. His shirt was soaked, plastered to his frame.
‘Kate, if not for your dad, then for his kids. They’re waiting inside to meet you.’
Kate stopped in her tracks. ‘They?’ she said. Her voice was brittle. ‘How many has he got?’
‘Two. He’s brought his son and daughter.’
A brother she’d only met once as a baby, and a sister she didn’t even know existed. Kate’s teeth began to chatter in the rain. Paul stood over her, the rain rolling down his forehead and into eyes full of urgent anxiety.
‘Why?’ she said. ‘Why do you care?’
He caught hold of her arms and turned her to face him. ‘Because I care about you,’ he said.
The rain was now a torrential downpour. Paul raised his voice above the sound of the water beating hard on the rooftops. Raindrops ran in rivulets down his face and over his lips. ‘I might be an idiot. I might have done this all the wrong way. But I care about you. This is your only family. You have to give them a chance, before it’s too late.’
Her body was shaking, but she forced her mouth open to speak. ‘It’s not fair. Not fair of you to ask. Not fair of him to come here after all this time and blackmail me with his children like this.’ She gave a violent shiver, half anger, half misery. ‘And it’s especially wrong that you even thought about contacting him without telling me. I cannot believe you did that.’ Her anger consumed her so that she could barely articulate herself. The words stuck in her throat, and she heaved great breaths.
Paul gripped her arms. ‘No, I know. Nothing about it is fair. And I shouldn’t have contacted him without letting you know. But I didn’t want to see any more lies printed about you. I thought I was looking after you.’ For a moment he held her, bending his head over hers in a vain attempt to shelter her from the rain. Then he dropped his hands to his sides. ‘Come on inside.’ He made an attempt at a smile. ‘In case you hadn’t noticed, it’s raining.’
With this passage, I tried to have the storm add an extra dimension to the heroine’s sadness and her turbulent emotions. The part where the hero is “bending his head over hers in a vain attempt to shelter her from the rain” is also symbolic. Paul would like to protect Kate from all the hurt she’s experienced in her life, but it’s impossible. He can only do what he can.
I love to use symbolism in this way, and I really enjoy deciphering the symbolism in other writers’ books, so I enjoyed writing about this topic a lot!
* * *
How about you? If you’re a reader, do you enjoy it when an author uses symbolism? How about in films? And if you’re a writer, do you use symbolism yourself? And do you have any great examples of when the weather has been used as a symbol?
If you have any comments at all, I’d love to hear them!
And if you’d like to read what my author friends have written on this topic, please click on the following links to find out:
Skye Taylor http://www.skye-writer.com/blogging_by_the_sea
Rachael Kosinski http://rachaelkosinski.weebly.com/
Beverley Bateman http://beverleybateman.blogspot.ca/
Connie Vines http://connievines.blogspot.com/
Anne Stenhouse http://annestenhousenovelist.wordpress.com/
Judith Copek http://lynx-sis.blogspot.com/
Dr. Bob Rich http://wp.me/p3Xihq-EP
Victoria Chatham http://victoriachatham.blogspot.ca
Kay Sisk http://kaysisk.blogspot.com
Rhobin Courtright http://www.rhobinleecourtright.com
30 thoughts on “Pathetic fallacy – symbolism and the weather in fiction”
Great post, Helen and an enjoyable snippet from your book. Like you I often use the weather to reflect the emotions of my characters, to the extent I wonder if I use it too much. Your post also had me googling the difference between pathetic fallacy and personification – my early morning lesson!
Hi Annika, that’s a good point about whether the symbolism can be overdone. I suppose it’s a fine line between adding depth to the story – or irritating the reader! And I’m guessing pathetic fallacy is a form of personification. Isn’t it good we’re no longer at school and not being tested!
So glad you enjoyed the post. Thanks very much for your comment!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Excellent topic. I agree. I love to add the weather as a backdrop to enhance the mood of my characters. In Deadly Undertaking, during an explosive meeting between the good guy and the bad guy, lightning and the cracking thunder match the anger and struggle going on inside the old barn between the two men. Don’t you smile a little when you write the scene and wonder if the reader will get the idea you are using to ramp up the drama? I first recognized all the symbolism and “meaning” in writing when I took a class in college on Shakespeare’s sonnets. I loved tearing his writings up to find the “real” meaning of his words. Pathetic fallacy is a new term to me. Thanks.
Hi JQ, I remember the thunderstorm scene in your novel. It was really dramatic and added a lot to the tension! I absolutely love the symbolism in Shakespeare’s language. You can read his sonnets again and again and still find something new.
Thanks for dropping in, and for your great comment.
Great post, Helena. I’m pathetic where symbols are concerned. I never get them. Someone always has to point them out. LOL So no I don’t consciously use them in my writing. You’ve done a lovely job here in this excerpt. This is perhaps my favorite of your books. I’ll share.
There is a type of writing that is completely free of symbols, Marsha, and I think your stories work really well. They are direct and your style of writing fits your characters perfectly.
I’m so glad you enjoyed A Way from Heart to Heart. Thanks so much for sharing!
Thank you Helena! I had never heard the term pathetic fallacy even though Waugh was prescribed school reading and I continued reading him after I left school. The snippet from your book also gave me food for thought.
It’s been another interesting topic, Victoria. I still read Waugh now, too. Thanks very much for dropping in!
I love the symbolism behind an atmospheric setting! It can say so much about the character’s emotions. Great excerpt, Helena :)
It’s great to find another fan of symbolism, Jacquie! :) And I’m so glad you enjoyed the excerpt. Thank you so much for dropping in, and for your comment!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The symbolism angle is something I didn’t think of before, but I love it. Great excerpt, by the way. I might just have to go download that book.
Hi Skye, I’m so happy you like the excerpt – thank you!! I really enjoyed this topic. I’m looking forward to checking out everyone else’s posts. Thanks so much for dropping in!
I do use weather in my all of my Kay Driscoll mysteries. In The Ginseng Conspiracy. Kay and her husband have a day outing to an art museum walking through a park to get there. Everything is bright and beautiful. Then she gets pushed into traffic. She still wants to see a Camille Pissarro exhibit. On the way back through the park after dusk, everything is scary, the trees, a jogger coming up to them, shadows, etc.
Good post, Helena.
Hi Susan, I love the way the day becomes more and more sombre and threatening in your story. It’s a while since I read The Ginseng Conspiracy. thanks for reminding me.
I’m so glad you enjoyed the post. Thanks for dropping in!
I love to read figurative language and personification Helena. The read that I started last night gives the fields human attributions and for me, it’s very visual :)
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a great way to describe the setting. It sounds an interesting read, and an unusual way to immerse the reader from the start. Thanks for the comment, Shaz, and for dropping in!
Very interesting post. I’ve never heard of ‘pathetic fallacy ‘ before and I don’t think I’ve used it. I may know. Thanks. Your use of weather in A Way From Heart to Heart is excellent. It really adds depth and emotion to the scene.
Thanks so much for dropping in, Beverley, and for your kind comment about my extract. I enjoyed writing that scene very much – and I really enjoyed this topic, too!
Helena, it made me happy how you’re enthusiastic about symbolism. In middle school and high school, my teachers really shoved symbolism down our throats and for a time I hated any sort of writing that got too metaphoric, etc. I’m still a little wary around them because school gave me the connotations of symbols being too high brow, but your post is really nice and shows how great symbols in books can be!
Hi Rachael, it’s such a shame when school ruins something for you like that. I absolutely love Jane Austen, but it took me a long while to re-read Emma because I had to pore over it at school so much I couldn’t bear to look at it again for a long time afterwards.
I do love symbolism, though, and I love to spot it in books and films. I’m so glad I made it seem like fun again. (And Emma is a brilliant book!)
I loved your post. Thanks so much for dropping in on mine, and for your comment!
Hi Helena, despite being rather well educated, I’d never been sure what pathetic fallacy meant – and now I know. thank you. Will use it at my next book group when, by coincidence, the book s A Handful of dust, anne Stenhouse
What a coincidence! And such a coincidence that you mentioned Evelyn Waugh in your own post. It’s a long while since I read A Handful of Dust. Now I want to read it again. Thanks very much for dropping in. I enjoyed your comment very much!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Helena, that passage really got me in. Instant characterization, powerful emotions, which you couldn’t have elicited so well without the downpour.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks very much, Bob! I enjoyed writing that scene very much. This has been another great topic. Thanks for dropping in, and for your kind words!
As an English major a long time removed from university classes, i had totally forgotten what the pathetic fallacy was. What a weird name! Thanks for reminding me. Enjoyed your post Symbolism rocks!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Judy, I agree about pathetic fallacy being a weird description! There’s nothing pathetic about it at all. I think (although I’m not sure) that in Victorian times “pathetic” would refer to emotions, as in “pathos”. That would make sense.
Symbolism does rock! Thanks very much for dropping in!